| |
Definition
What is a Mountain?
Literature on mountains is extensive and voluminous.
Yet, there is no rigorous definition of universal acceptance
of what constitutes a mountain. Most discussions on
mountains and their development merge the concept of
montaigne (Old French, meaning a considerable height)
with the concept of the old English term hill (small
mound), and these are not the same. Such transposition
is also evident in the poetic imagery of Wilfrid Noyce
(1954, p 294):
Everest: terror and love:
No veil is upon you, no cloud
Doubts the huge hump, mighty monument set on earth,
Harp of the wind, snow-song and avalanche tears,
And tinier tale of men. But men are so proud,
Their mole-story is hill-high (see Plate 1).
According to Geoffrey Winthrop Young,
a mountain is "earth set on earth a little
higher." Thus, it is relative and subjective—that
is, whatever strikes fire in the imagination. Therefore,
one person's mountain is another person's knoll (Hanson
1988, p.8). The definition provided by a classic on
mountain geography (Peattie 1936, p 1) is similar:
"A mountain, strictly speaking,
is a conspicuous elevation of a small summit area. A
plateau is a similar elevation of a larger summit area
with at least one sheer side. An essential yet indefinite
element in the definition of a mountain is the conspicuity.
Conspicuity, like height, is a relative matter, and
depends upon the evaluation or the standard by which
it is measured."
In other words, a mountain is a mountain
because of the part it plays in popular imagination.
Therefore, the cult of the mountain (shugendo) as a
sacred place and poetic eulogies such as those characteristic
of Meghadut (Kalidasa, 5th Century), Die Alpen (Albrecht
von Haller, 1708-77), Wilhelm Tell (Johann Christoph
Friedrich von Schiller, 1759-1805), and Childe Harold
(George Gordon, Lord Byron 1788-1824). Mountains may
be considered sacred, sublime, and beautiful. They also
happen to be marginal areas for human occupancy due
to their high altitude and steep gradient. Yet, the
mountain is not an amorphous mass but a composite of
elevation zones. This is evident from indigenous terms
from the mountains of Nepal such as pahar (hill without
snow), lekh (ridge with winter snow), and himal (range
with permanent snow). These terms are indicative of
socioeconomic zones with intensive land use at lower
levels, extensive use at intermediate levels, and no
use at upper levels.
This regional survey of a land mass
as large as Asia needs objective criteria. Thus, only
those ranges and plateaus that exceed 1,000 masl have
been considered as mountains; and this includes high
hills also. Thus, the enquiry has been confined to altitudinal
zones of hochgebirge (glaciated) and mittelgebirge (non-glaciated)
mountains as defined by natural science. An overview
of this kind, focussing on conspicuous ranges, cannot
provide an in-depth regional analysis of a composite
environment and its interaction with the adjacent lowlands.
Hence, the preference given to the term mountain area instead of mountain region, as this is the appropriate
terminology for the spatial aggregation.
|